Castaway Cay Vacations from $1,200

I love the property but the staff is very unwelcoming and very disrespectful, grutity

The property shows clear signs of aging and is in need of substantial renovation. Several areas had peeling paint on the ceilings and walls, and the bathroom fixtures, including the faucets, were rusted. While the oceanfront view from my room (1032) was outstanding, the room furnishings were outdated and the mattress was uncomfortable. On a positive note, the buffet was very good—tasty with plenty of options. Unfortunately, the other restaurants were disappointing, with food that seemed pre-made and was often overcooked.

The staff had to be the friendliest I’ve ever encountered. The Concierge service was excellent. Nothing bad to say about this property. Absolutely loved our stay at The Rosewood Bah Mar. Looking forward to returning.

Loved the secludiveness of this property. Although it's an all adult there still happened to be babies, kids and young teens. Nothing to overwhelming BUT they should have another pool for the kids or for JUST ADULTS. The place did have a smell to it but your in a different country so nothing is really going to be A1. They do try to sell you a luxury Vacation (like a Timeshare but it's nowhere near) tip: lest questions and interest you'll be out in 30-90 min! But can take ALL DAY!! Ask for accommodations if presentation takes longer and into your vacation time. Overall it was a nice property!

This is a gem , clean room , friendly staff. Juanita have all your needs ,she has contact for everything in Harbour island and Eleuthera. We stayed off season and she made sure we had everything we needed during our stay. Nice on site restaurant as well! Can’t go wrong!